Is Honda Amaze Diesel Still Worth Buying? Amaze Petrol Vs Diesel | V3Cars

04 August 2021
By Mahesh Yadav
0

Honda recently increased the prices of all of their cars. The Amaze and WRV diesel variants got hit especially hard. After the August 2021 price increase, is it still worth buying the Honda Amaze diesel? Let’s find out.

Update (Feb 16, 2022): Please refer to the latest mileage and fuel cost comparison of the Honda Amaze petrol and diesel models to help you decide which one is right for you:

Honda Amaze Petrol Or Diesel? Mileage & Running Cost Comparison

Honda Amaze Petrol vs Diesel Old Prices

First, let’s look at the old prices to see what extra premium you were paying earlier for the Amaze diesel over the Amaze petrol:

Honda Amaze Petrol vs Diesel Prices (Before August 2021)
Variants	Old Petrol Prices	Old Difference	Old Diesel Prices
E MT	Rs. 6,22,439	Rs. 1,46,006	Rs. 7,68,445
S MT	Rs. 7,00,939	Rs. 1,34,756	Rs. 8,35,695
V MT	Rs. 7,60,439	Rs. 1,35,256	Rs. 8,95,695
VX MT	Rs. 8,08,438	Rs. 1,35,256	Rs. 9,43,694
S CVT	Rs. 7,90,938	Rs. 1,24,756	Rs. 9,15,694
V CVT	Rs. 8,50,439	Rs. 1,25,256	Rs. 9,75,695
VX CVT	Rs. 8,91,437	Rs. 1,07,563	Rs. 9,99,000

*Note: All prices ex-showroom Delhi

Honda Amaze Petrol vs Diesel New Prices (August 2021)

Now, let’s see how much premium you will have to pay for the Amaze diesel over the Amaze petrol after the price increase:

Honda Amaze Petrol vs Diesel Prices (August 2021)
Variants	New Petrol Prices	New Difference	New Diesel Prices
E MT	Rs. 6,32,000	Rs. 2,34,500	Rs. 8,66,500
S MT	Rs. 7,10,000	Rs. 2,10,000	Rs. 9,20,000
V MT	Rs. 7,70,000	Rs. 2,10,000	Rs. 9,80,000
VX MT	Rs. 8,18,000	Rs. 2,03,000	Rs. 10,21,000
S CVT	Rs. 8,00,000	Rs. 1,99,900	Rs. 9,99,900
V CVT	Rs. 8,60,000	Rs. 2,00,000	Rs. 10,60,000
VX CVT	Rs. 9,01,000	Rs. 2,10,000	Rs. 11,11,000

As you can see, the price difference has shot up quite a bit. Earlier you were paying a premium of Rs. 1.08 lakh to Rs. 1.46 lakh for the diesel engine. Now, the difference is Rs. 2.0 lakh to Rs. 2.35 lakh. The premiums for the diesel engine have shot up by about Rs. 68,000 to Rs. 1.02 lakh depending on the variant. Refer the following table:

Variants	Old Diesel Premium	Change	New Diesel Premium
E MT	Rs. 1,46,006	Rs. 88,494	Rs. 2,34,500
S MT	Rs. 1,34,756	Rs. 75,244	Rs. 2,10,000
V MT	Rs. 1,35,256	Rs. 74,744	Rs. 2,10,000
VX MT	Rs. 1,35,256	Rs. 67,744	Rs. 2,03,000
S CVT	Rs. 1,24,756	Rs. 75,144	Rs. 1,99,900
V CVT	Rs. 1,25,256	Rs. 74,744	Rs. 2,00,000
VX CVT	Rs. 1,07,563	Rs. 1,02,437	Rs. 2,10,000

Kilometres to Recover or Breakeven With Honda Amaze Diesel

The Honda Amaze petrol promises a mileage of 18.6kmpl with the manual and 18.3kmpl with the automatic transmission. With an estimated Rs. 102/litre price of petrol in Delhi, it’ll cost Rs. 5.48 to cover 1km with the Amaze petrol manual and Rs. 5.57/km with the Amaze petrol automatic.

With the diesel manual, the Amaze claims to deliver 24.7kmpl while the diesel automatic only has a mileage figure of 21kmpl. At an estimated Rs. 90/litre for the diesel fuel, the Amaze diesel will have a fuel cost of 3.64/km with the manual and Rs. 4.29/km with the automatic.

Honda Amaze Cost Per km
	Petrol	Diesel
Fuel Price Estimate (Delhi)	Rs. 102	Rs. 90
Manual Mileage	18.6kmpl	24.7kmpl
Manual Cost Per km	Rs. 5.48/km	Rs. 3.64/km
Automatic Mileage	18.3kmpl	21kmpl
Automatic Cost Per km	Rs. 5.57/km	Rs. 4.29/km

Earlier, based on these ex-showroom prices and the official fuel-efficiency claims, you needed to drive the Amaze diesel manual for about 73,000 to 80,000km to recover the difference in upfront ex-showroom cost. After the August price update, you need to drive about 1.1 to 1.3 lakh km to break even on the higher upfront ex-showroom price of the diesel Amaze.

With the automatic, the situation is even worse. For the Amaze diesel automatic, the breakeven kilometre figure has almost doubled for some variants. Earlier, compared to the Amaze petrol automatic, the diesel automatic needed to be driven 84,000 to 97,000km to recover the cost. Now, you will have to drive the car for as much as 1.63 lakh km to recover that cost. With the Amaze diesel automatic, not only do you get a lower mileage figure but also lower torque and power output. With the Amaze petrol automatic, you don’t compromise much - if at all - on any of these parameters.

Note that prevailing Delhi fuel cost of Rs. 102 for petrol and Rs. 90 for diesel. These calculations are done using the official ARAI mileage figures as the baseline.

Variants	Old KM to Recover	Change in KM	New KM to Recover
E MT	79,345	48,091	1,27,436
S MT	73,231	40,890	1,14,121
V MT	73,503	40,619	1,14,121
VX MT	73,503	36,814	1,10,317
S CVT	96,856	58,339	1,55,195
V CVT	97,244	58,029	1,55,273
VX CVT	83,508	79,528	1,63,036

Should You Buy The Honda Amaze Diesel After Price Increase?

The numbers make the picture a lot clearer. While the petrol prices are going up, diesel is also getting expensive. And such a high premium for a diesel engine makes little sense in our opinion to go for diesel.

The benefits, however, still remain in favour of the diesel engine. For example, the diesel engine has more torque, better drivability and longer refill intervals because of the higher mileage per tank. If these factors are important to you, only then you should consider buying the Honda Amaze diesel at these prices.